Free US shipping on orders over $35 · Order advent calendars by Friday, Nov 20 for Dec 1 arrival

Painted mimic chest, mimic coffin, mimic cauldron and crawler miniatures in front of the Codex Kirtrite Arcanum advent calendar

A Free D&D Mimic Encounter: The Hall of Twins

Every DM has run a mimic. The trouble is that it only works once. After the first chest bites someone, your players poke every chest in the dungeon with a ten foot pole, and the mimic stops being scary. The Hall of Twins is the encounter I wrote to make mimics scary again, by telling the players up front that they are there. It is a free, printable 5e encounter for four characters of level 3 to 5, and it drops into any dungeon with a door at each end. I run a 3D-printing studio in Utah and I’m a DM and avid gamer, and like our free pirate encounter, this one is built around a set of miniatures I print myself.

What Happens in the Hall of Twins

At the heart of a minotaur labyrinth sits a hall run like a counting house. Three alcoves hold three pairs of treasures: two chests, two cauldrons and two coffins. In every pair, one is honest and one is a mimic. A winged devil called the Pale Auditor makes every visitor the same offer: open the honest twin and keep what is inside, open the liar and you pay the house. Her minotaurs make sure nobody touches both. Along the south wall stand the last party who took the deal, turned to salt.

How the Encounter Runs

The puzzle is physical. Characters can study one item at a time to find its tell. The mimic chest has a warm, damp latch. The mimic cauldron’s soup ripples in time with something breathing. The mimic coffin’s nails are teeth. Fail a check badly and you touched the thing, which settles the question in the worst possible way.

The Auditor never lies. She answers questions in exact, legal phrasing and will never say which twin is which. Clever questions delight her. A pseudodragon named Tally, kept in a cage beside her throne, hates her and will trade a hint for a promise of freedom.

The bell makes every mistake louder. A great bronze bell hangs in the middle of the hall. It rings when someone opens a mimic, attacks the Auditor or casts something loud, and each ring brings the next wave out of the labyrinth: vermin first, then a giant spider and a rust beetle, then a wolf, a panther and a foaming slime, and finally the crawler. When the fourth wave arrives, the warden slams the labyrinth door, and the only way out is through the Auditor.

The minotaurs only enforce the rules. They will stand there while a mimic eats someone who chose honestly but badly. Waves from the labyrinth attack anyone, minotaurs included, which a sharp party will use.

Four Ways It Can End

A party that finds all three honest twins walks out rich, and the Auditor offers them a job. A party that opens a liar leaves marked, and the devil will come to collect someday. Tear her ledger and the salt statues come back to life, grateful and owing the party their lives. Or ring the bell four times, get sealed in, and bargain with a devil for the only door left. The PDF also has a closing wager for the house take, which is the meanest thing in the booklet.

The Cast, and the Miniatures That Play Them

Every creature and prop in the encounter matches a miniature in Storm the Dungeon, one of the four themes in our Premium Dice Advent Calendar. That set is 19 miniatures plus 7 pieces of dungeon dressing, including the three matched pairs where one of each is a mimic. It also has the winged devil, three minotaurs, every wave creature, and six heroes your players can use as their own party or stand along the wall as salt statues.

You do not need the calendar to run it. Any dungeon minis work if you cast by silhouette: one winged leader, three big brutes, a handful of beasts in rising sizes, and three ordinary objects your players will never trust again. If you only want one mimic for your own table, our Treasure Chest Mimic comes as a closed chest and a reveal pose, and the rest of the cast lives in our dungeon miniatures. The hall itself plays great on dungeon terrain if you would rather build it than print the map.

Download the Encounter

Download the free encounter (PDF)

Download the DM map (17 by 11 PDF)

Download the player map (17 by 11 PDF)

The PDF is 20 pages in our quest book style: the full encounter, a table setup guide, the house rules, the tells, the bell track, nine stat blocks built from the SRD 5.1, treasure, scaling notes and the miniature gallery. A full-size 17 by 11 map of the hall comes with it, in a DM version with every position marked and a clean player version. Print it, run it, and share it with your table.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need the advent calendar to run this encounter?

No. It works with any miniatures, or tokens on a grid. The calendar just happens to contain every creature and prop in it, including all three mimic pairs.

What level is it for?

It is built for four characters of level 4, and the PDF includes adjustments for level 3, level 5, and smaller or larger groups. The puzzle carries most of the difficulty: a careful party might only ever fight one mimic, while a reckless one can bring the whole labyrinth down on the hall.

How do I stop players from just attacking every chest?

That is the point of the rules. Attacking or touching both items in a pair turns the minotaurs hostile, and attacking the Auditor turns everyone hostile. The only safe way to the treasure is to study, ask, and choose.

How long does it take to run?

Plan on 60 to 90 minutes. Most of that is the puzzle, and the bell keeps the fights short and sharp.

If your players have never been afraid of a treasure chest, start here. For something with fur, Last Call at the Silver Stag is our free werewolf encounter. If you are still deciding between a dice or miniature calendar, Storm the Dungeon now comes with its own encounter, and the other three themes do too: Low Tide at Gallows Bar, Hold the Bridge and The Dark Lamp. For a full one-shot, Shadows Over Silverlake is our vampire quest, and the gifts for TTRPG players guide covers everything else. You can find the whole cast in the Premium Dice Advent Calendar.

Consult the Oracle.

Bring the Story to Your Table

Every Kirtrite miniature, terrain piece, and accessory is 3D printed in-house in Utah — built to be played with, not just displayed.

Join the Kirtrite Adventurers' Guild

New releases, painting tips, and first dibs on seasonal drops.

Consult the Oracle Further